Fishkill Plains vs Highland Mills

Poughkeepsie, NY Neighborhood Comparison

Fishkill Plains and Highland Mills cost about the same: $580k vs $570k (Redfin, Jul–Sep 2026).

Neighborhood A
Fishkill Plains
$580k median
View Fishkill Plains profile →
Neighborhood B
Highland Mills
$570k median
View Highland Mills profile →
Not sure which fits you? Start planning →
Fishkill Plains
Metric
Highland Mills
$580k
→
Median Price
$570k
8/10
·
School Rating
not compared: missing on one side
N/A
Fishkill Plains
Median Price
100%
Highland Mills
Median Price
98%
🔄 Try Different Neighborhoods 📍 All Poughkeepsie Neighborhoods

Not Sure Which One Fits You?

Answer a few questions and get your personal top 3 matches in Poughkeepsie — ranked by lifestyle, budget, schools, and commute.

Start planning →

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Fishkill Plains or Highland Mills more expensive?

Fishkill Plains has a median home price of $580k and Highland Mills is $570k. Highland Mills is the more affordable option.

Which has better schools — Fishkill Plains or Highland Mills?

Fishkill Plains has a school rating of 8/10 and Highland Mills rates None/10 (school ratings from Niche/GreatSchools, 1 to 10, by school rather than by street).

Which is more walkable?

Fishkill Plains has no Walk Score on file. Highland Mills has no Walk Score on file. Walk Score isn't available for one of these neighborhoods.