South Pier vs Pigeon River

Sheboygan, WI Neighborhood Comparison

South Pier's median sale price is $405k, about $105k (35%) more than Pigeon River's $300k (Redfin, Jul–Sep 2026).

Neighborhood A
South Pier
$405k median
View South Pier profile →
Neighborhood B
Pigeon River
$300k median
View Pigeon River profile →
Not sure which fits you? Start planning →
South Pier
Metric
Pigeon River
$405k
→
Median Price
$300k
South Pier
Median Price
100%
Pigeon River
Median Price
74%
🔄 Try Different Neighborhoods 📍 All Sheboygan Neighborhoods

Not Sure Which One Fits You?

Answer a few questions and get your personal top 3 matches in Sheboygan — ranked by lifestyle, budget, schools, and commute.

Start planning →

Frequently Asked Questions

Is South Pier or Pigeon River more expensive?

South Pier has a median home price of $405k and Pigeon River is $300k. Pigeon River is the more affordable option.

Which has better schools — South Pier or Pigeon River?

South Pier has a school rating of 0/10 and Pigeon River rates 0/10 (school ratings from Niche/GreatSchools, 1 to 10, by school rather than by street).

Which is more walkable?

South Pier has no Walk Score on file. Pigeon River has no Walk Score on file. Walk Score isn't available for one of these neighborhoods.