Redfin neighborhood sale median for Jul–Sep 2026 for Tolleston; 115 homes sold there over the 12 months Oct 2025–Sep 2026. One figure for the whole neighborhood; individual homes sell above and below it. We do not publish a low/high range because we do not have a sourced one.
Tolleston is a neighborhood in Gary, Indiana with a Suburban, Quiet vibe.
Answer a few questions to get your personal top 3 neighborhood matches in Gary — ranked by lifestyle fit, budget, schools, and commute.
Find My Match in Gary →The median sale price in Tolleston is approximately $125k (Redfin neighborhood sale median, Jul–Sep 2026). Individual homes sell above and below that figure depending on size, condition and exact location.
We do not have a school rating for Tolleston. Check assigned schools for any specific address with the district.
Tolleston is a neighborhood in Gary.
We don’t grade neighborhoods on crime. Look up the streets you’re considering in Gary with the agency that patrols them:
Chris Harris, REALTOR® · Real Broker, LLC · Kentucky license #299754
Equal Housing Opportunity
Privacy · Terms · About Chris · Guides
If Chris introduces you to an agent outside Kentucky, he may receive a referral fee from that agent's brokerage. It doesn't change your price.