Home › Neighborhoods › Youngstown, OH

Best Neighborhoods in Youngstown, OH

Mahoning County · Ohio
34
Neighborhoods with 5+ sales, Oct 2025–Sep 2026 (35 listed)
$100k
Citywide median sale price (Redfin city median, Jul–Sep 2026)

All 35 Youngstown Neighborhoods

Compare Youngstown neighborhoods side by side →

Glen Park Estates
$360k · 13 sales
Forest Glen Estates
$290k · 21 sales
Herron Heights
$270k · 12 sales
Applewood Acres
$257k · 35 sales
Hitchcock Woods
$235k · 15 sales
Mount Vernon Woods
$235k · 12 sales
Woodland Trace
$232k · 14 sales
Highland Park
$228k · 54 sales
College Park
$225k · 12 sales
Kimberly Acres
$203k · 17 sales
Kirkmere
$184k · 76 sales
Indianola Heights
$180k · 10 sales
Huntington Woods
$177k · 36 sales
Boardman Park
$158k · 30 sales
Northeast Warren
$150k · 110 sales
Oak Hill
$150k · 8 sales
Wickliff
$144k · 46 sales
Westgate Park
$135k · 12 sales
Southeast Warren
$133k · 113 sales
Northwest Warren
$131k · 102 sales
Schenley
$117k · 66 sales
Brownlee Woods
$117k · 36 sales
North Heights
$110k · 52 sales
Belle Vista
$103k · 62 sales
McGuffey Heights
$100k · 17 sales
Idora
$95k · 20 sales
Lansingville
$77k · 63 sales
Pleasant Grove
$72k · 22 sales
Buckeye
$63k · 22 sales
Central Warren
$62k · 37 sales
Lincoln Knolls
$59k · 13 sales
Warren
$55k · 18 sales
Newport
$53k · 14 sales
Cottage Grove
$38k · 20 sales

Neighborhoods below had fewer than 5 recorded sales in the window, or are not in Redfin’s neighborhood list; their medians are a rough guide, not a ranking.

Canfield Estates
$292k · fewer than 5 sales

Not Sure Which One Fits You?

Answer 4 quick questions and get your personal top 3 matches in Youngstown — ranked by lifestyle, budget, schools, and commute.

Start planning →

Check crime data

We don’t grade neighborhoods on crime. Look up the streets you’re considering in Youngstown with the agency that patrols them: