Youngstown, Ohio · Mahoning County

Cottage Grove Neighborhood Guide

Cottage Grove is a neighborhood in Youngstown.
$38k
Median Price
Where the $38k median comes from

Redfin neighborhood sale median for Jul–Sep 2026 for Cottage Grove; 20 homes sold there over the 12 months Oct 2025–Sep 2026. One figure for the whole neighborhood; individual homes sell above and below it. We do not publish a low/high range because we do not have a sourced one.

About Cottage Grove

Cottage Grove is a neighborhood in Youngstown, Ohio with a Suburban vibe.

Nearby Neighborhoods in Youngstown

Pleasant Grove
$72k
Brownlee Woods
$117k
Southeast Warren
$133k
Westgate Park
$135k
Northeast Warren
$150k
Boardman Park
$158k
Huntington Woods
$177k
College Park
$225k

Does Cottage Grove Sound Like Home?

Answer a few questions to get your personal top 3 neighborhood matches in Youngstown — ranked by lifestyle fit, budget, schools, and commute.

Find My Match in Youngstown →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the median home price in Cottage Grove?

The median sale price in Cottage Grove is approximately $38k (Redfin neighborhood sale median, Jul–Sep 2026). Individual homes sell above and below that figure depending on size, condition and exact location.

How are the schools in Cottage Grove?

We do not have a school rating for Cottage Grove. Check assigned schools for any specific address with the district.

What is Cottage Grove known for?

Cottage Grove is a neighborhood in Youngstown.

Check crime data

We don’t grade neighborhoods on crime. Look up the streets you’re considering in Youngstown with the agency that patrols them: